Eric Johnson and Jessica Simpson’s highly publicized relationship, culminating in a 2014 wedding and subsequent 2025 divorce, was preceded by Johnson’s marriage to stylist Keri D’Angelo. Their union, solemnized in a 2005 Napa Valley ceremony, lasted a mere four years before the couple separated in 2009, ultimately finalizing their divorce in 2010. This timeline becomes significant in light of the controversy that erupted surrounding the beginning of Johnson and Simpson’s romance, with allegations of infidelity casting a shadow over their early days together.
The narrative of Johnson and Simpson’s relationship begins with a whirlwind romance. A mere six months after meeting in 2010, Johnson proposed to the singer and actress. Simpson, smitten with the former NFL player, often romantically recounted their initial encounter, describing it as a fairytale moment where she opened her door to him and “never let him leave.” Their relationship quickly progressed, marked by the births of their daughter Maxwell in 2012 and son Ace in 2013, prior to their lavish 2014 wedding. They later welcomed their third child, daughter Birdie, in 2019, completing their family.
However, the seemingly idyllic romance eventually faced significant challenges. Behind the public facade of a happy family, the couple was navigating a difficult period in their marriage. By 2025, their separation became public knowledge, with Simpson issuing a statement confirming the split and emphasizing their commitment to prioritizing their children’s well-being. The statement, released to Us Weekly, highlighted the painful nature of their situation and requested privacy as they navigated the complexities of their separation as a family.
The timeline of Johnson’s relationships becomes a point of contention with the emergence of allegations surrounding his split from D’Angelo. While Johnson and Simpson’s relationship began officially after his divorce from D’Angelo was finalized in October 2010, reports surfaced suggesting an overlap between the two relationships. A friend of D’Angelo’s came forward in 2011 alleging that Johnson had been unfaithful during their marriage, claiming he was still involved with D’Angelo while simultaneously pursuing Simpson. This accusation, published in Star magazine and later reported by the Daily Mail, painted Johnson as a “two-timing cheat” and cautioned Simpson against marrying him.
These allegations, while denied by Simpson’s representatives at the time, cast a shadow over the beginning of her relationship with Johnson. The claim that Johnson was intimate with both women during a period of overlap between the relationships raised questions about the timeline and the nature of his involvement with Simpson. The controversy, though ultimately fading from the headlines, added a layer of complexity to the public perception of Johnson and Simpson’s relationship, particularly in its early stages.
Despite the initial controversy, Johnson and Simpson proceeded with their relationship, culminating in a decade-long marriage. The allegations of infidelity, while never substantiated, remained a part of the narrative surrounding their relationship’s beginnings. Ultimately, their journey together concluded with their separation in 2025, marking the end of a highly publicized and often scrutinized relationship that began with a whirlwind romance and ended with a quiet, private separation. The focus, as stated by Simpson, shifted towards their children and navigating the challenges of co-parenting amidst the aftermath of their divorce.
