The future of New York Mets first baseman Pete Alonso remains uncertain as the free agency period continues. While a return to Queens is still possible, Alonso is exploring other options, leaving the Mets to contemplate potential replacements. One such candidate is Detroit Tigers slugger Spencer Torkelson, who, despite a promising 2023 season, experienced a significant dip in performance in 2024. This downturn, coupled with a potentially crowded Tigers infield in 2025, makes Torkelson a potential trade target for the Mets, according to reports.
Torkelson, the first overall pick in the 2020 MLB Draft, burst onto the scene with a strong 2023 campaign, showcasing power with 31 home runs and driving in 94 runs, while maintaining a respectable .758 OPS. However, his 2024 season was a stark contrast, with his OPS plummeting to .669, accompanied by a significant drop in home runs and RBIs. This inconsistency raises questions about his long-term potential and whether he can regain his 2023 form. The emergence of Gleyber Torres at second base and Colt Keith at first base further complicates Torkelson’s position within the Tigers organization, making him a potential trade piece.
The Mets’ interest in Torkelson stems from several factors, including his remaining four years of team control, aligning with the team’s cost-conscious approach under president of baseball operations David Stearns. Torkelson’s defensive capabilities at first base are also attractive, allowing Mark Vientos to continue developing at third base without positional disruption. Acquiring Torkelson would represent a calculated gamble for the Mets, betting on his potential to rebound from a disappointing 2024 season. This potential move underscores the growing likelihood of a separation between the Mets and their homegrown slugger, Pete Alonso.
The financial implications of a potential Torkelson acquisition are also significant. With an estimated salary of $800,000 for 2025 and not eligible for arbitration until 2026, Torkelson represents a considerably more affordable option compared to Alonso. This cost-effectiveness would be particularly appealing to the Mets following their substantial investment in star outfielder Juan Soto. While Soto’s offensive prowess is undeniable, his acquisition represents a significant financial commitment, making cost-effective solutions at other positions crucial for maintaining a balanced roster.
The potential trade for Torkelson presents both opportunities and risks for the Mets. On one hand, it allows them to acquire a young, cost-controlled player with demonstrated power potential, while also solidifying their infield defense. However, Torkelson’s inconsistency raises concerns about his ability to consistently produce at the major league level. The Mets would be banking on his ability to recapture his 2023 form and become a reliable contributor to their lineup.
Ultimately, the decision of whether to pursue Torkelson hinges on the Mets’ evaluation of his long-term potential and their willingness to gamble on a player coming off a down year. It also depends heavily on Alonso’s decision in free agency. If Alonso departs, Torkelson could represent a viable, albeit less proven, alternative. This potential move highlights the dynamic nature of the MLB offseason and the difficult decisions teams face in balancing financial constraints with the pursuit of talent. For the Mets, the pursuit of Torkelson could represent a shrewd move to address a potential vacancy at first base while remaining fiscally responsible, or it could be a gamble that doesn’t pan out. Only time will tell if this potential trade comes to fruition and whether Torkelson can fulfill his potential in New York.
