The Cleveland Browns’ quarterback situation is poised for an intriguing development in 2025. Despite the recent restructuring of Deshaun Watson’s contract, which ensures his presence in Cleveland for the upcoming season, his role as the starting quarterback is not guaranteed. NFL Network insider Ian Rapoport has suggested the possibility of a veteran competition for the QB1 spot, naming Aaron Rodgers and Kirk Cousins as potential candidates. This revelation adds another layer of complexity to the Browns’ plans, creating a potential quarterback controversy.
The prospect of Aaron Rodgers joining the Browns hinges largely on his situation with the New York Jets. Rapoport indicated that if Rodgers isn’t with the Jets in 2025, Cleveland could be a viable landing spot. This scenario is further complicated by the potential departure of Jets wide receiver Garrett Wilson, who reportedly might seek a trade if Rodgers remains with the team. The intertwined fates of Rodgers and Wilson add an element of uncertainty to the Jets’ future and potentially open a door for the Browns.
The inclusion of Kirk Cousins in the conversation raises questions about his future with the Atlanta Falcons. It seems that Cousins’ time with the Falcons has effectively ended. Despite a narrow victory over the Las Vegas Raiders, the Falcons chose to replace Cousins with Michael Penix Jr. following four games in which Cousins threw eight interceptions without a single touchdown pass. With Penix Jr.’s performance seemingly convincing the Falcons he is the quarterback of the future, Cousins’ availability for the Browns becomes a tangible possibility.
For the Browns, the potential availability of veteran quarterbacks like Rodgers and Cousins presents a compelling alternative to drafting a rookie. While holding a high draft pick in 2025 – currently fourth overall going into Week 17 – offers the chance to select a promising young quarterback, the experience and proven track records of Rodgers and Cousins could be alluring. The decision facing the Browns involves weighing the benefits of a seasoned veteran against the potential of a developing rookie.
The Browns’ quarterback dilemma is further complicated by the financial implications of Watson’s restructured contract. The move provides salary cap flexibility for 2025 and 2026, but it also signifies a commitment to Watson, at least financially. Should the Browns decide to pursue either Rodgers or Cousins, they would need to navigate the complexities of having a highly-paid backup quarterback. This situation creates a delicate balancing act between financial prudence and the pursuit of on-field success.
The unfolding quarterback saga in Cleveland promises to be a major storyline in the coming months. With Watson’s future uncertain, the potential pursuit of established veterans like Rodgers or Cousins, and the looming 2025 NFL Draft, the Browns face a crucial decision regarding their quarterback position. The choices made by the Browns’ front office will undoubtedly shape the team’s trajectory in the coming seasons, setting the stage for either continued uncertainty or a renewed sense of direction.
