The Southern Methodist University (SMU) Mustangs are gearing up for a monumental clash against the Clemson Tigers in the Atlantic Coast Conference (ACC) championship game, a contest that carries significant implications for their playoff aspirations. As the team prepares for this high-stakes encounter, they will be accompanied by a familiar symbol of their institution’s spirit – Peruna IX, the beloved Shetland pony mascot. However, the decision to include Peruna in the pre-game festivities has ignited a fierce debate between the university and animal rights advocates, particularly People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA).
PETA, a prominent voice in animal welfare, has vehemently opposed Peruna’s presence at the championship game. In a strongly worded letter addressed to SMU President R. Gerald Turner, the organization implored the university to reconsider its decision, characterizing it as a “senseless stunt” and an “archaic tradition.” PETA’s primary concern revolves around the potential stress and anxiety that Peruna might experience in the boisterous and overwhelming environment of a packed stadium. The organization argues that ponies, being prey animals, are inherently sensitive to loud noises and large crowds, making the stadium atmosphere potentially distressing for the animal.
PETA’s argument hinges on the assertion that parading Peruna in front of a stadium teeming with cheering fans, noisemakers, and a marching band would subject the pony to an unnecessarily stressful situation. The organization contends that such an environment could trigger the animal’s natural instinct to flee, potentially leading to panic and injury. PETA Senior Vice President Kathy Guillermo further emphasized this point, stating that ponies, like all living beings, deserve to be treated with respect and not used as mere props for entertainment. She urged SMU to prioritize Peruna’s well-being and discontinue the practice of using a live mascot altogether.
SMU, however, stands firm in its tradition. Peruna’s presence at SMU football games stretches back to 1932, evolving over time from charging the field after touchdowns to leading the team onto the field and running between quarters. The university views Peruna as an integral part of its identity and game-day experience, and maintains that the pony is well-cared for and accustomed to the stadium environment. While acknowledging PETA’s concerns, the university hasn’t indicated any intention to alter its plans for Peruna’s participation in the championship game.
This clash between tradition and animal welfare highlights the complex ethical considerations surrounding the use of live mascots in sporting events. While universities often view live mascots as cherished symbols of school spirit and tradition, animal rights organizations argue that the animals’ well-being should take precedence. The debate raises questions about the balance between honoring tradition and ensuring the ethical treatment of animals, a balance that remains a subject of ongoing discussion.
The ACC championship game, taking place at Bank of America Stadium in Charlotte, North Carolina, carries significant weight for both SMU and Clemson. The outcome of this game will determine the conference champion and influence the teams’ chances of securing a coveted spot in the College Football Playoffs. Amidst the excitement and anticipation surrounding the game, the controversy surrounding Peruna’s presence adds another layer of complexity to the event. The debate serves as a reminder of the broader ethical questions that arise when tradition intersects with animal welfare, a conversation likely to continue beyond this particular game.
